Twenty Quid, Three Spins: A Winter Crate Dare for Under-Priced LPs
Photo by Photo by Jonny Gios on Unsplash on Unsplash
Winter is the right season for a record-buying dare. The nights are long, the shop lights are warm, and the bargain bins are full of records that somebody else has already paid the collector tax on. The Splid £20 Winter Challenge is not about finding a mint first pressing or a grail you can flip on Discogs. It is about taking a chance on one second-hand LP you would normally walk past, playing it three times, and deciding whether it has earned its place on the shelf before Christmas.
The rules, more or less
Set a hard ceiling of twenty quid. One record only. It has to come from an independent shop — not a car boot, not a supermarket reissue rack — and it has to sit outside your usual lane. If you only buy soul, buy jazz. If you only buy jazz, buy post-punk. Listen all the way through three times: once with headphones, once while doing something else, once with a mate. Then report back. That is it. No grading spreadsheets, no investment committee.
Five records that still turn up for twenty notes
These are not rare. That is the point. They are records that sold in decent numbers, get filed away in the wrong sections, and often sit in the £8–£18 bracket because they are not fashionable this week. All five reward repeated listening, which is the only test that matters here.
The Blue Nile – A Walk Across the Rooftops
A Linn Records original can still be found for under twenty pounds if you look past the £30 online listings. It is the kind of record that sounds like a city in the rain, all soft-focus synths and late-night bus windows. Check for a clean vinyl surface and a sleeve that has not gone fuzzy at the edges. The music is slow-burn, so give it all three spins before you decide. If it clicks on the second listen, you have a winter keeper.
Steel Pulse – Handsworth Revolution
UK reggae with a sharp political edge and a warm, rootsy pulse. Copies turn up in soul and reggae sections for £12–£20, often with a bit of ring wear on the sleeve. Do not ignore a copy because the cover is scuffed. Check the vinyl under a strong light; if it is glossy with only light paper marks, it is worth a punt. Play side one loud enough to hear the bass properly. This is a record that makes a cold kitchen feel like a community hall.
Cowboy Junkies – The Trinity Session
Recorded in a church with one microphone, this is the opposite of a collector flex: quiet, spacious, slightly haunted. It turns up in folk and country bins for £15–£20, usually because the cover is plain and the band name does not scream bargain. Look for a copy with the original inner sleeve and no deep scratches. If the shop will play it, ask them to drop the needle on the first track. The silence between the notes is part of the record, so check for crackle that would sit on top of it.
Keith Jarrett – The Köln Concert
A solo piano record that sold by the truckload and still gets underpriced because it is filed under jazz and looks like a charity-shop cliché. A clean two-LP copy should be £10–£15 in most independent shops. Check both discs, not just the first one. The sleeve often splits along the spine, which is annoying but not a deal-breaker if the price is right. Three listens will tell you whether the long improvisations are mesmerising or just long. For a lot of people, it is the former.
The Selecter – Too Much Pressure
2 Tone ska with a pop kick and a serious undertow. Copies are common, but they are not always cheap because the cover looks good on a wall. You should still find a playable original for £15–£20. Check for warping near the edge and make sure the labels are not bubbling. The record is short and punchy, so the three-spin rule is easy to keep. It also works as a gateway: if you like this, the shop probably has more 2 Tone in the same crate.
Sleeve-side detective work
Before you hand over anything, take the record out. Hold it at an angle to the light and look for deep scratches, not just hazy paper scuffs. Check the spindle hole for heavy wear, which can mean the copy has been played to death on a tired deck. Look at the runout etching if you are curious about pressing details, but do not let a matrix number talk you into paying over the odds. A shop copy with a written name on the label is fine if the vinyl is clean; a shiny sleeve with a gouged record is not.
Ask the staff if you can hear a track. Most independent shops will happily put a record on the shop deck, and it is the quickest way to spot a warp or a repeat. Check the inner sleeve too: a torn original inner is not a disaster, but it can tell you how the record has been stored. And look in the sections where the record should not be. Under-priced copies often hide in folk, blues, easy listening or soundtracks because the person filing did not know where else to put them.
The point of the dare
The £20 Winter Challenge is not about building a collection that looks good in a photo. It is about training your ear to take a risk. Buy one record that makes you slightly unsure. Listen to it properly. If it does not work, take it back to the shop or pass it on to a friend. If it does, you have added something with a story attached — and you have kept a few quid in the local record economy rather than feeding an online bidding war.
Report back to Splid with what you found, what you paid and whether it earned its keep. We will be doing the same. The best crate-digging discoveries are rarely the ones you planned.